5 Buy-To-Let Mistakes To Avoid

In this article
Not able to pay mortgage
★★★★★ Rating:
Talk to an Expert

Receive latest news, tips, and guides to help you navigate your homeownership journey!

*By clicking Subscribe, you agree with our Privacy policy .

Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Investing in the UK's buy-to-let market can be a profitable business opportunity, but many challenges come with it. To avoid costly mistakes and ensure a successful venture, it is important to navigate the complexities of this arena carefully. Although the potential rewards are attractive, making mistakes can lead to negative financial consequences. Despite the challenges involved, the buy-to-let market can be a profitable investment opportunity with the proper knowledge, meticulous planning and a proactive approach. You can maximize your returns and build a successful buy-to-let portfolio by avoiding common pitfalls and staying up-to-date with the latest regulations and market trends.

5 Key Mistakes

1. Underestimating Costs

One of the most significant errors landlords make is failing to accurately estimate the total expenses of managing a buy-to-let property.  

Mortgage costs

It is not uncommon for buy-to-let mortgages to be interest-only mortgages. This means that the principal amount of the mortgage loan is not required to be repaid until the end of the mortgage term and any increases in mortgage rates apply to the full loan amount. As mortgage interest rates have increased dramatically since early-December 2021, the interest costs of many buy-to-let landlords have increased by about three times. With rental incomes having remained relatively flat over the same period and mortgage interest relief restricted to only 20% of interest costs for income tax purposes, this increase in mortgage increase costs has led to severe financial consequences for many landlords. Landlords would be well advised to consider the risks associated with mortgage costs carefully when considering mortgage financing for their buy-to-let investments.

Estate agent commissions and fees

It is quite common for buy-to-let landlords to market their properties to potential tenants through estate agents. Estate agents’ letting commissions can be as high as 9 – 11% (plus VAT) of annual rent and can also increase broadly in line with inflation. In addition, if the property is also managed by an estate agent, their management fee can be a further 5 – 7% (plus VAT) of the annual rent. Landlords do not always appreciate and anticipate the magnitude of the impact of such estate agents’ commissions and fees.

Service charges

Whilst individual, stand-alone properties can often be freehold, flats are typically located within buildings with other flats and are frequently leasehold. Many buy-to-let properties are flats. The owners of buy-to-let flats, as leaseholders, are typically required to pay annual service charges to the freeholder for the maintenance of the common parts, roof, communal garden and boundary walls, and for buildings insurance, the reserve fund, security, emergency works and so on. Service charges can amount to a significant proportion of annual rent and can also escalate with inflation.


Many landlords overlook the costs associated with maintenance and repairs, which can accumulate rapidly. These could be related to all manner of things, including boilers, central heating, plumbing, electrics, safety, water leaks, furniture, furnishings, decoration, carpets, garden maintenance and so on. Some of these costs can be covered by insurance policies, which themselves can be reasonably expensive and subject to escalating annual premia.


Landlords must also be prepared for other costs, such as void periods when the property is unoccupied or occupied by tenants who have stopped paying rent, legal costs associated with eviction, and the costs of rectifying damage caused by tenants. If not factored into investment calculations, such costs can be a severe additional strain on cash flow.

2. Not Researching the Local Market and Tenant Demand

Investing in a buy-to-let property without a strong understanding of local market dynamics can be a recipe for disaster. Landlords must conduct thorough research to assess tenant demand, rental levels and property values in the areas they intend to invest in. It is important, for example, to avoid mismatches between properties being offered and tenant demand, and between landlords’ and tenants’ rental expectations. Likewise, it is important to consider property price appreciation prospects.

Additionally, investors should consider factors such as proximity to amenities, transportation links and employment opportunities, as these can significantly influence tenant preferences and the overall desirability of the location.

3. Choosing the Wrong Property or Location

The success of a buy-to-let investment relies heavily on the location and type of property chosen. While some regions experience positive growth in property values and rental rates, others may stagnate or even decline, directly impacting rental income and capital appreciation.

To ensure a successful investment, landlords should thoroughly evaluate the local housing market trends, economic indicators and demographic data. This will help identify areas with strong potential for long term growth and sustained demand. Additionally, landlords should consider the needs and preferences of their target tenant demographic, whether it be families, young professionals or students, and ensure that the property aligns with those needs.

4. Failing to Screen Tenants and Manage the Property Properly

Inadequate tenant screening is a significant error that can lead to many problems, including rent arrears, property damage and costly evictions.  Landlords should implement a comprehensive screening process that includes credit checks, employment verification and reference checks to attract responsible and reliable tenants. Additionally, effective property management is essential, encompassing regular inspections, prompt maintenance and clear communication with tenants to maintain a positive landlord-tenant relationship.

5. Ignoring Legal Requirements and Tax Rules

The buy-to-let industry is subject to a web of legal requirements and tax rules that landlords must navigate carefully. Ignorance of these requirements can lead to disputes, legal issues, fines, penalties and costs that may ultimately jeopardize the investment.

For example, the restriction of mortgage interest cost deduction for tax purposes over the last few years has resulted in only 20% of interest being eligible for deduction now. When rapidly rising interest rates and stagnant rents lead to lower profits or even losses, this restriction bites even harder.

Furthermore, landlords must stay updated on tenant rights, safety regulations and local housing laws to ensure compliance and avoid potential legal disputes, penalties and costs.


Avoiding these common pitfalls in the buy-to-let market requires diligence, meticulous research and a proactive approach. Regularly reviewing property management practices, staying proactive with maintenance and remaining current on landlord-tenant laws are critical to success. By addressing these key mistakes head-on, landlords can mitigate risks, maximize returns and create a sustainable and profitable buy-to-let investment portfolio.


Q. What are the most significant financial mistakes buy-to-let investors make?

A: The biggest financial mistakes include overestimating rental income, not accounting for all expenses and investing in areas which are unlikely to experience significant property price appreciation.

Q. How can I avoid choosing the wrong property for a buy-to-let investment?

A: To avoid choosing the wrong property, conduct thorough market research, consider the location carefully, ensure it meets the needs of the target tenant demographic, and assess profitability and return on investment prospects thoroughly.

Q. What are the legal responsibilities of landlords?

A: Legal responsibilities include ensuring the property's safety (gas, electrical, fire), protecting tenant deposits, proper maintenance, providing an Energy Performance Certificate and following eviction laws.

Q. How can I effectively screen tenants for my buy-to-let property?

A: Screen tenants by conducting credit checks, obtaining references from previous landlords and employers, verifying income and meeting them to assess compatibility.


1. Research reveals UK landlords' maintenance costs run into thousands a year – how much should you budget for? | Simply Business | Released on: 23 July 2019
2. LGA Releases empty homes report, in partnership with The Empty Homes Network | Empty Homes | Released on : 14 November 2023
3. Preliminary Analysis: Eviction Filing Patterns in 2022 | Eviction Lab | Released on: 9 March 2023
4. Restricting finance cost relief for individual landlords / HM Revenue & Customs | Gov.uk

Reduce interest costs

Make your BTL work again! Pauzible pays the increase in your mortgage costs for up to 5 years, in return for a share in the value of your buy to let property.

Get Started
By clicking “Got it”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.
Get Started